How RNG made me happy for once

I’ve shared my thoughts about randomness in MMORPGs before, my verdict being that it can be good or bad depending on how it’s utilized.

The RNG elements in Black Desert Online, of which there are many, are mostly bad in my opinion. Losing a bunch of progress you’d already made with a single click, for example when an item downgrades again due to a failed upgrade attempt, is just the antithesis of fun.

So color me surprised when the game’s third anniversary came along and with it an event that had a kind of RNG I actually liked quite a lot.

This event gave us the opportunity to earn four pre-enhanced pieces of gear. Spread across four weeks you could get one temporary accessory piece and some event-only upgrade materials per week by doing a quest and being logged in for a certain amount of time every day.

If you were lucky and got that piece to enhancement level TRI you could then exchange it for a regular accessory piece, also at TRI level. A huge prize! The real kicker, at least for me, was that even if you weren’t that lucky you’d at least get a DUO version of that same piece at the end of the week, provided you’d completed the quest (which required to kill a thousand mobs of a specific type) each and every day. At that time a DUO accessory was still a big deal for Lakisa and myself, so I knew that doing the event would be a win no matter our amount of luck.

It went really well, much better than anticipated. After week three we both had already scored two TRI hits, so we had to settle for the ‘consolation DUO ‘ only once each. In week four the best of the items was up, the Ogre Ring (which is actually worn as a necklace, apparently Ogres have pretty thick fingers). Unfortunately Lakisa only got the DUO this time, I on the other hand…

BDO_TRI1
It is indeed, my dear Rudd, it is indeed

I was very excited to get it – I made Lakisa jump in her seat by cheering rather loudly – and also pretty happy with the event as a whole. Getting those TRI items was obviously huge, but, again, the fact that we at least got a DUO whenever the RNG wasn’t in our favour was what made the event feel really rewarding and fun to me. I would’ve also been happy, if a bit disappointed of course, if I’d scored only one TRI, or even none at all. I guess I can enjoy randomness much more if it’s not either win it all or lose it all. Not winning the main prize stings much less if I at least get an adequate reward for my efforts so that I don’t feel like all I did was for nothing.

Anyway, that particular day the RNG gods weren’t quite done being nice. After finishing the event quest we did some boss scrolls, and I finally got a pair of Bheg’s Gloves while Lakisa was even luckier and received Dim Tree Spirit’s Armor. What are the chances of that happening on the same day?

As if that still wasn’t enough I pulled a DUO Eye of the Ruins Ring from a Dark Rift reward box later that same evening. Say what?

BDO_TRI2
Finally cracked that 200 AP threshold; I didn’t think I’d ever get there

Whoa. Not only did all that additional attack power boost my damage output quite noticably, having made such a substantial leap on the gear ladder actually motivated me to try and push even further. Since I now had Bheg’s Gloves lying around, as well as a Kzarka weapon box I got during another event a while back, I decided to buy the remaining boss armor pieces I wanted, namely Dim Tree, Griffon’s Helmet and Urugon’s Shoes, from the market and have a go at enhancing them all at once, which is the most efficient way anyhow.

BDO_TRI3
All prepared and ready to dance the failstack dance

I knew that 300 Armor Black Stones wouldn’t be enough to build all those failstacks I’d need, but I kinda hoped that the rest of the items you see up there, especially the Memory Fragments, would suffice. Haha, not a chance. Over the span of three hours I used up about 700 Mem Frags, well over 1k Black Stones, more than 100 Concentrated Black Stones, 50 Valk’s Cry, almost all Advice of Valk’s I had and like 100 million silver. But I got there.

BDO_TRI4
So beautiful it almost didn’t hurt anymore

At the time of this writing those five items have a combined worth of about 4,5 billion silver on the marketplace, so I actually made a profit, hard to believe as it may be. Still, I’m glad I got it over with. From here on out I’ll only try to enhance anything when I have accumulated enough Cron Stones so a failure won’t bounce the item back to DUO.

The only thing left to do then was to bring the remaining accessory slots up to par. I had long since decided that I’d never try to enhance those myself – because they don’t just fall back a level when an enhancement attempt fails, they are destroyed instead – so I’d held on to any I’d found in order to sell them later and use the silver to buy already enhanced pieces from the market.

I activated a 7-day Value Pack and put all kinds of stuff I had accumulated over the months up for sale. Just 12 hours later I’d made almost 2,5 billion silver. I used that to buy a second TRI Narc Ear Accessory and a TRI Eye of the Ruins Ring. Not satisfied with wearing one last DUO piece I then sold that DUO Eye Ring and also the DUO Ogre Ring I had lying around since after the anniversary event to buy another TRI Eye Ring.

BDO_TRI5
As a huge fan of symmetry this pleases me to no end

It’s ironic, and also a bit schizophrenic I feel, that I still don’t like this gear upgrade system at all, yet looking at what I’ve achieved with it makes me feel really satisfied and happy.

But, again, it probably wouldn’t have happened at all if not for the anniversary event and its rather generous and rewarding form of RNG.

Anyway, at the end of that arduous play session it suddenly occurred to me that I had no idea what those shiny new items actually look like on my character since he’s always wearing the costume you’ve already seen in numerous screenshots. So I toggled the hide costume switch.

BDO_TRI6
911? Yeah, there’s some nutter in a bird suit loitering on the bank’s roof

Ehhhh…I think I’ll stick with my costume, thank you very much.

 

 

Advertisements

Sov warfare can be fun after all

The ongoing war between Goon-led Imperium and PanFam doesn’t nearly make as much headlines as other wars in EVE Online have – and rightly so, unfortunately.

That’s not to say nothing’s happening – there’s fighting going on pretty much around the clock, every day. However, measured by the huge number of players involved the amount of destruction happening is rather miniscule. ISK-wise the highest damage isn’t done when combat fleets clash, but far off the front lines whenever yet another ratter or miner gets caught with their pants down by the other side’s raiding patrols or even third parties looking for easy kills.

I believe the main reason for this is that there’s actually not much at stake for both sides. Goons have stated from the beginning that they have no intention to hold on to whatever space they manage to take from us. Which means that, once they’re gone, we’ll just take it back. It’s not like anyone but Goons would be able to stop us from doing that.

As for ISK-damage done, that doesn’t matter a whole lot either. Both coalitions are more than capable of replacing any ships, citadels and whatever else the war might claim many times over.

Until now there’s been only one important and numbers-wise relatively huge fight – which Lakisa and I unfortunately missed due to it being very early in the morning in our timezone – after Goons had managed to reinforce the infrastructure hub in SH1-6P, our coalition’s main staging system. Had they succeeded to destroy it our position in this war would’ve been severely weakened. Our forces won that battle pretty decidedly and the I-hub was saved.

EVE_SovExplosion
Since I wasn’t there here’s a shot of an exploding Astrahus citadel instead

That linked article also talks a bit about the game’s current sovereignty mechanics. As usual you can read about it in more detail on EVE Uni’s Wiki, if you’re so inclined. This system, referred to as Fozzie Sov by most players, is in the game since 2015 when it replaced the Dominion Sov system introduced in 2009.

No one really likes Fozzie Sov much, just like no one really liked Dominion Sov. Or the system before that. The thing is – apart from the fact that MMO gamers in general and EVE bittervets in particular are never happy anyway – I don’t think it’s at all possible to devise a sov system that favours neither attacker nor defender too much and completely negates waiting periods and the chance for a whole lot of boredom.

That’s because you can’t actually force either side of a conflict to do anything. Whenever the attackers have reinforced a thing there has to always be a timer after which they have to come back and do another thing, so the defenders have a chance to react. There’s three possible scenarios for that to go down.

One – The defenders decide to not show up, either because they know they can’t win or they just don’t care. Everyone’s bored.

Two – The defenders show up in force, so much so that the attackers don’t like their chances and retreat or don’t show up in the first place. Everyone’s bored.

Three – Actual fighting happens, at least one side is happy. Probably the other side too, because considering the alternatives EVE’s PvPers generally like to get a fight at all, even if it doesn’t go their way in the end.

So no matter how the sov system works there will always be a good chance that you’re forming up for nothing.

That being said, last Sunday we were treated to an example of how fun Fozzie Sov can actually be. We lost the objective in the end, but most of us agreed that it was the most fun we’d had in quite a while.

Goons had reinforced some stuff in our home region Vale of the Silent, and we formed up in force to defend. Once the timer was up command nodes would begin to spawn randomly anywhere in the Z-DO53 constellation’s systems. PL and us formed a joint Muninn fleet, Horde came in Eagles.

EVE_SovPotato
Muninn fleet on the move in ‘potato mode’

In preparation for large numbers and the associated strain on the game’s client I dialed down the graphics to minimum settings, referred to as potato mode, disabled all sound – I really hate playing without sound – and turned off some other bits and pieces. The maximum fleet size of 256 pilots was reached well before we even undocked, and there were still people trying to get in. Hence having your client crash would most likely have led to losing your spot in the fleet, so I wasn’t gonna risk anything.

We were Titan-bridged into EIDI-N and waited there for the timer to tick down. Meanwhile multiple Imperium fleets were reported in KRUN-N, right next door. Since there was still time I fired up dotlan and assessed the situation.

EVE_Sov
As always, click to enlarge

I knew that we actually might have some fun when I saw the constellation’s layout and our starting position in it. Many constellations have kind of a ‘main road’ which you have to take if you want to reach every system in it. Often those are the fights that end before they even begin because neither side is willing to jump in first and be at a disadvantage from the get go. Here, though, we had many connections between systems, and apart from the IPAY-2 and V-OJEN branches neither side would be able to block the other from going anywhere by locking down just one stargate.

Sure enough, as soon as the first command nodes spawned we were off, zipping to and fro, trying to protect our ‘toasters’, the entosis-fitted ships that have to interact with the nodes, while killing off theirs. I say zipping…actually more like crawling, because there were over 800 pilots in the constellation already and TiDi was hitting pretty hard.

Time Dilation was CCPs answer to coalitions bringing more and more people into battles, crashing their servers left and right. Nowadays when a server is at maximum load everything gets slowed down to give it more breathing room. For us players this means the game effectively runs in slow motion, down to 10% of its normal speed at worst.

Additionally and unrelated to TiDi, session changes – for example when jumping through a gate or taking a jump bridge – have waiting queues when hundreds of people do it at the same time.

EVE_SovTraffic
We spent quite some time staring at this, though it rarely takes as long as it says

Nevertheless it was extremely fun. I think our FCs did a great job, but the true heroes were our Interdictor pilots. They dropped critical bubbles just at the right time and place more than once, ensuring that we didn’t get caught by fleets twice our size.

Still, after a while it became clear that we wouldn’t be able to win this. Even more reinforcements for Goons arrived while Horde’s fleet was effectively out of combat because they lost almost all of their logi due to some mishap. So at that time it was pretty much our lone 250 pilot Muninn fleet against all that stuff you see on the battle report’s red side. Time to cut our losses and go home.

Many people on our side say things like “Goons can only win when they outnumber us 4:1” or “If they blob us like that all the time they are the ones to blame when nobody gets good fights”. While that’s technically true I wonder what else they should do? I mean, are they supposed to fill up just one fleet and tell everyone else to stay at home? Just the other day Wilhelm portrayed what fleet formup looks like right now if you’re in the Imperium, and as I said, our own fleet was full too. Everyone wants a fight, that’s what we play EVE for. The difference is, if you combine all characters in the alliances on our side of that battle report you get about 24,300. The red side’s characters add up to almost 58,000.

So, yeah, being outnumbered will continue to be our lot in this war. As long as we get some good fights out of it I don’t care much. And, as I said, when it goes like it did on Sunday I might even start to actually like sov warfare. Who would have known?

13 1/2 years of EVE Online – Part III

After leaving the ISS towards the end of 2006 I took a break from EVE for about two years. I mostly kept my main account running to continue learning skills and run a mission or two every now and then, but my main game was Everquest II, which I played very extensively.

After many great folks had left my long-time EQII guild my motivation to play the game took a serious hit though, and I started thinking about internet spaceships again.

It was then that a friend of mine told me about a huge war that was going on, and that his corp, Lyonesse, part of KIA Alliance, was right in the middle of. So I sent an application to the corp’s leadership and prepared to move my stuff out to nullsec again.

EVE_History13
A common sight in null by then, a Titan sitting inside a POS’s shields

That war, today known as The Second Great War, was fought between Band of Brothers, the self-proclaimed “elite” of EVE, and Goonswarm, whose battlecry at the time was “We’re terrible at this game” and who aimed to shake up the established order. They were basically space anarchists.

BoB considered themselves unbeatable. For a couple of years they pretty much were. As if dominating New Eden’s landscape and scoring the first ever Titan kill wasn’t enough they’d also won the first three Alliance Tournaments in a row – which is why there was much rejoycing when they got their butts handed to them by a bunch of Tech I cruisers in AT IV.

In any given conflict I usually root for the underdog, so I was more than happy to join Lyonesse and KIA Alliance, who were allied with Goonswarm, to prove that BoB weren’t unbeatable in the regular game either. Unfortunately it turned out that I was late to the party.

Since its launch in 2003 EVE has always made headlines not only due to huge battles happening, but also with tales about deceit, theft and treachery. The arguably biggest such event happened just a few weeks before I joined the corp and moved to Peroid Basis. The BoB alliance was stripped of most valuable assets and then disbanded by a high ranking officer defecting to Goonswarm. The alliance being disbanded made them lose control of all their systems and outposts, which finally enabled Goons and allies to attack “Fortress Delve”, as BoB had previously dubbed their practically impenetrable home region, in force.

By the time I was combat-ready BoB were pretty much defeated and the first fleets I joined revolved around ‘mopping up’, as it were. We tried to catch as many BoB pilots, most of whom had reformed under the name KenZoku by then, while trying to evacuate their remaining assets from the area. There weren’t many left, but that doesn’t mean we had nothing to shoot.

EVE_History12
Dreadnoughts full guns blazing with battleships providing cover

Goons weren’t the only ones set on taking the now vacant space in Delve and Querious, and KIA’s systems in Period Basis were being harassed by a couple alliances living in nearby Stain whenever we were on the road.

For me this was the first time I operated under the Not Blue, Shoot It ruleset, and it was pretty fun. Overall I didn’t get all that much action due to working in shifts and hence missing many a fleet op, but I nevertheless had many ‘firsts’ during that time.

Firsts like catching a faction fitted Navy Raven ratting in an asteroid belt. We were doing a late night roam through Stain with just a couple Interceptors, an Interdictor, a Harpy and a Vagabond. Whenever we entered a system and saw someone in local we all warped to different belts in hopes of one of us picking the right one and catching the pilot unawares. When I landed in that belt my heart skipped a couple of beats because a Navy Raven was sitting right there. I immediately tackled it, started to orbit it with my maximum non-boosted speed to present as small and fast a target for its missiles as possible and told my mates to warp to me stat.

While they were still in warp I suddenly lost my target lock. The pilot had put his ECM-drones on me, and they’d successfully landed a jam cycle. You can’t tackle what you can’t lock, so I had to do something lest he get away. I hit the ‘approach’ button and fired up my microwarpdrive. Me sitting in an Interceptor meant that I picked up speed quickly, and I bumped into him with like 3 km/s. I don’t know if that really prevented him from warping off in time, but he was still there when my buddies arrived either way. While my Malediction eventually succumbed to the damage dealt by his missiles we got that kill and over 300 mil worth of loot for our efforts. I was as pleased as a punch to have managed the initial tackle and to hold him long enough for the gang to arrive.

I also got to fulfill one dream of mine: to fly a blaster-fitted Megathron battleship, Blasterthron for short, into battle. Blasters are kind of an all-or-nothing weapon system. They deal the highest damage of all turret types in the game. To offset that they have an effective range of pretty much the length of my pinky toe, so if you decide to get into that range you either win the engagement or you die. Those Thoraxes in the AT video I linked above were blaster fitted, which is why their stunt was so risky yet probably wouldn’t have worked any other way. I don’t remember why we even used close-range battleships that day, but the fight we got was just exhilarating.

EVE_History14
Battleships aligning away from a gate to their next destination

I even got one of my very rare solo kills. This Huginn tried to slow me to a halt with its Stasis Webifiers but came too close in the process. It literally melted within seconds. Unfortunately the successful op came to an inglorious end for me when I took a wrong turn on the way home and found myself all alone in the middle of a hostile gatecamp. Oh well, another first.

The successful rescue of a friendly carrier I’ve talked about a while ago also happened during that time.

Last but not least I experienced my first big capital ship brawl and also scored my first cap killmails. If I remember correctly there was a fight over a valuable moon going to happen between Goons and allies on our side and Against ALL Authorities and friends on the other. We were still staging from TN25-J in Period Basis and all available pilots were told by one of our directors to board a long-range battleship and make our way to Irmalin, a cool 28 jumps away without shortcuts. Fortunately all of Period Basis, Delve and Querious was covered by an extensive allied jump bridge network by then, so it didn’t take quite as many jumps to get there. I was extremely nervous, but it was a tremendously fun experience.

EVE_History15
I’d never seen something as epic as this in any game before

Although I definitely don’t remember it that way the battle report clearly shows that we had vastly superior numbers, but, yeah, sometimes that’s the way it goes in EVE.

Not long after that fight Lyonesse decided to leave KIA Alliance. I did understand the decision because the alliance wasn’t in a good shape by then. Leadership was mostly absent and there were less and less enemies to fight. It made me a bit sad though because I’d come to quite like a good many people of the other corporations. The overall atmosphere in our new alliance, RAZOR, was much more serious and at times even hostile towards one another. I didn’t feel welcome, let alone at home at all. So after almost a year in Lyonesse I decided that it was time to take a break from EVE once more.

The Cookies join Northern Coalition.

Yes, the big news I was talking about last week is that our EVE Online corporation Holy Cookie has joined Northern Coalition., or NC. (pronounced “N C Dot”) for short.

EVE_NCdot
The dot is even in the logo, so it’s important

It turned out that our directors had been in talks with Killah Bee, a prolific, long-time fleet commander of NC., for quite some time. To my surprise he’s also German and joined our corp meeting to discuss things with us and answer our questions. All attendees were pretty enthusiastic about the move, rejecting the invite was never even a considereration.

Personally, I was extremely excited about it and still am.

The main reason is that I haven’t been in a proper nullsec alliance for quite a while, and I kinda missed it. Sure, there are boring aspects to living out there, but anyplace else in New Eden can be equally boring while not providing the freedom and great opportunities for epic fights that basically only nullsec provides.

Another reason I’m happy to have joined NC. is that they and their allies are kind of the arch enemies of Goonswarm. While I have fought alongside Goons a very long time ago – more about that in part three of my EVE history series – since Mittani is in charge they have pretty much become the very thing they were once opposed to, at least to my mind. Getting another chance to kick their butts after Lakisa and I fought them during World War Bee back when we were in Mercenary Coalition is awesome.

The timing couldn’t have been better either, because Mittens has just decided to attack NC.-space in force. Not to take it for the Goons, but only to see it burn. They started moving their war machinery on Saturday. Let them come, I say.

But first things first. Before heading out to nullsec we had a lot of preparation to do since we had amassed quite a lot of stuff in and around our lowsec-home Kehjari by now. Ships, clones and other assets had to either be brought to highsec, be it for safekeeping or for sale, or hauled quite a distance out to our new home.

We also had to consider what to do about our security status, which was at or close to -10 due to our pirating ways. While that isn’t a problem in nullsec per se I know from experience that nullsec fleets, since they often need to cover large distances, use any shortcut they can get, so trips through highsec are always a possibility.

Lakisa and I decided ‘repairing’ our sec status before the move to be the prudent thing to do. We bought the needed tags from the market and took them to the nearest CONCORD office.

EVE_NC1
Tags aren’t enough, you charge an additional fee? What is this, the German government?

Getting our status to above -2.0 set us back about 280 million each. Yikes. At least we can now move around freely anywhere in New Eden again.

Hauling everything we needed to get rid of to highsec took a while, but we did so without losing anything and have already liquidated most of it. Alliance doctrine ships can be bought locally, so we didn’t really have to bring a lot of stuff with us. One trip in my carrier was all it took, and we were ready to go.

Which was fortunate, because a fleet op was about to start the moment we arrived. We quickly bought a pair of Eagles off contracts, set up voice comms and joined the fleet.

EVE_NC2
Eagles and support landing on a stargate

Unfortunately we didn’t get a fight that day. We reinforced a hostile Fortizar, but no one came to defend it.

The day after things looked more promising. A Goon Ferox fleet was reported to roam around M-OEE8, the entry system into Tribute (nullsec currently owned by NC. and allies) from Lonetrek (high- and lowsec). We formed Eagles again and made our way there.

We arrived at the perfect moment. Their fleet had become entangled in an array of warp disruption bubbles around the E-O gate. Killah warped us into position and the slugfest began.

EVE_NC3
A red overview is a good overview – at the start of a battle anyway

To be honest, it wasn’t a fair fight since we outnumbered them quite a bit, but of course that’s what you’re always looking for in EVE – or in any PvP game, really. Who wants a fair fight when you can just obliterate the enemy without casualties of your own, right? So we seized the opportunity and made short work of them.

EVE_NC4
Lots of wrecks on the field, none of them ours

Now this was the kind of action I’d hoped for.

A day or two later I was treated to a sight that’s old news for many nullsec veterans, but made my jaw drop a bit despite having seen it on screenshots numerous times. Turns out being there and seeing it for yourself is much more awe-inspiring.

EVE_NC5
A whole bunch of Titans sitting between a Keepstar’s uprights

My highlight by far was yesterday though, when Killah took a Muninn fleet deep into Delve, Goonswarm’s home region. With the bulk of their forces deployed in the north but seemingly not quite ready to attack us in earnest yet we now have a window of opportunity to hit them where it hurts without getting caps and supers dropped onto us.

A stealth bomber fleet of Pandemic Horde was to attack and reinforce some Goon Ansiblex jump gates, thereby disrupting their means of travelling to and fro quickly, and we provided cover for the bombers.

That cover was much needed, too. When fighting an alliance almost 35k characters strong their deployment elsewhere doesn’t mean that nobody’s home. As far as I could tell they had three sizeable fleets to oppose us; Jackdaws, Harpies and bombers. Local count climbed as high as 800 at times, with just around 300 of those fighting on our side.

Once Horde’s bombers attacked the first jump gate the hostile fleets started to zip around the grid, looking for an angle to shoot them from without being in our Muninn’s range, while we tried to counter just that.

EVE_NC7
Come and get some

Our Interdictors dropped bubbles constantly to deny their fleets the best warp-in angles. Every now and then a lone Interceptor looking to provide a good warp-in came too close and immediately felt the firepower of a couple dozen artillery platforms shooting in unison.

Then, we couldn’t quite believe our eyes, an enemy Phoenix class Dreadnought suddenly appeared on grid, right beside the jump gate. Obviously the pilot hadn’t gotten the memo of that gate being under attack and had blindly jumped through from the other side. I’ve never seen a Dread go down this quickly with only subcaps shooting it, but it wasn’t even fitted for fleet combat, so…yeah.

We all kept dancing around the gate without the enemy fully committing their fleets to defend. Eventually it was reinforced und thus rendered non-functional for at least the next ~23 hours while giving us a chance to come back and finish it for good after that time period.

We then moved on to the next such gate two systems away and repeated the process. I don’t know if this one was more important to them or if they’d just had enough of us at that point, but they now engaged us head on. Well, they tried.

EVE_NC8
The game is on

It was a slaughter. I could hardly lock the targets fast enough before they exploded. They admittedly killed a bunch of ships in return, mainly bombers, but the battle report still shows a pretty one-sided affair.

EVE_NC9
Mopping up while the remaining enemies retreat

The second jump gate had also been reinforced by then, so the op was a resounding success. For me and my corpmates it also was a massive adrenaline rush the likes of which we hadn’t experienced very often before, at least not on this scale. Extremely satisfied we made our way home.

Hopefully this was just the beginning.

13 1/2 years of EVE Online – Part II

The Interstellar Starbase Syndicate was an alliance that pursued a quite unique and in my opinion really cool goal in ’05 and ’06: to make nullsec accessible for anyone.

Nullsec space is an incredibly valuable commodity and always has been. Back then the most valuable moons, asteroids and hostile NPCs were exclusively found out there, so it’s no surprise that many corps and alliances tried to claim as much space for themselves as possible. I assume the term NBSI, “not blue, shoot it”, was penned around that time, because folks were fiercely protective of their territories (‘blue’ in EVE means flagged as a friend or ally).

The ISS wanted to tread a different path. They set out to create truly neutral areas of nullsec where anyone could come and go as they pleased to mine, rat, manufacture or just explore with impunity. To provide some infrastructure for players without the means to deploy their own POSes the ISS even strived to build public outposts. At the time building those was a pretty huge undertaking, hence there weren’t many of them around yet, and those that were usually didn’t allow anyone but their owners to dock.

An IPO was launched in September 2005 to acquire a cool 36 billion ISK for the construction of EVE’s first public player built outpost. It was the first IPO in an MMO ever. It succeeded, and one month later ISS Marginis opened its doors in KDF-GY in the Catch region.

EVE_History6
My first visit of what would become my home for a while

To defend construction endeavours and uphold law and order in ISS space a military arm, the ISS Navy, was formed. I figured this would be a perfect fit for me since I’d already dreamed of being a protector of innocent and law-abiding citizens back in Ultima Online – only it never came to pass because the Felucca/Trammel split had already happened and there wasn’t anyone left on Felucca to protect.

So I packed my stuff again (this will be a recurring theme and is pretty much the only thing in EVE I could really do without), moved into Marginis and joined the Navy.

In the weeks and months that followed I learned how to move and fight in a PvP fleet, what all the commands and abbreviations fleet commanders use mean, how different ships fill different roles, how to setup my overview properly and so forth. I especially learned a lot from an FC named Butter Dog (the name still cracks me up), an outspoken and upfront, but mostly friendly Brit who already had quite a lot of experience.

I also learned how to make and use warp-to-zero bookmarks. Whenever you warped anywhere back then your ship came out of warp 15 km shy, so you had to ‘slowboat’ to the gate, station or wherever you were actually trying to go. This made travelling exponentially more dangerous than it is today, so what you wanted to have was a bookmark created 15 km behind your destination, exactly in line with your respective point of origin. Folders of those bookmarks – once created by some poor sod with too much time on their hands – were sorted by region, copied and handed around. Depending on the amount of systems and stargates we’re talking about somewhere between 500 and 1000 bookmarks for a single region. All that saving and copying of bookmarks put so much strain on the servers that CCP finally gave us warp-to-zero a while later.

Doing our daily duty mainly meant roaming the space around KDF, blowing up or at least scaring away any would-be pirates. While we didn’t call it that our directive was pretty much today’s NRDS: not red, don’t shoot.

It’s been a long time and I’m fuzzy on the details, but I must have performed fairly well because I got promoted to Captain quickly.

EVE_History7
I even got a badge of sorts

Being Captain made me eligible to lead my own fleets – which I didn’t aspire to do to be honest – and take the role of Co-FC on bigger ops.

One such series of ops revolved around the next public outpost’s construction. When the IPO for this came around I invested 200 mil since Marginis seemed to generate nice profits, and I deemed it a project worthy of support in any case. If I remember correctly the shares were all sold within 24 hours, so production was soon to begin.

Huge quantities of resources had to be hauled to the target system, ZXIC-7. Freighters were the tool for that job, by far the slowest and least agile ships in EVE. Today everybody in low- and nullsec uses their jump-capable counterparts, but those weren’t in the game yet. Convoys were formed to carry all resources and parts from wherever they were mined or built to ZX, with all available Navy pilots escorting them.

EVE_History8
Freighters and smaller haulers on the move

The riskiest part was the final construction. Even back then I didn’t know the exact mechanics, all I know is that the outpost could have been attacked and destroyed during its final assembly. Our job was to basically lock the whole system down and make sure that no stranger got in from about 8 AM to 1 PM my local time. Which wouldn’t have been so bad if I hadn’t worked the night shift and only gotten to bed around 6. No matter, I wanted to be there!

EVE_History9
Cargo and Navy ships circling the construction platform aka ‘the egg’

I was given command over one of the squads assigned to camp the system’s stargates. For that duty I boarded my Megathron class battleship, which I had acquired not too long beforehand, and took position at my guns’ optimal range from our assigned gate. During those hours only few ships came through. We tackled and politely asked them to leave the system the way they’d come, else we’d have no choice but to remove them by force. I remember that one pilot started a lenghty discussion about how we had no right to prevent them from passing through. Since they were surely aware that we actually were very forthcoming – anybody else would have blown them to pieces right away – my guess is they assumed we were roleplaying and decided to play along.

No one came to shoot the egg. When the server went down I finally got some much needed sleep, so I wasn’t there when it went up again, but later that day I logged back in and marveled at the work we’d done. Mission accomplished!

EVE_History10
A thing of beauty…well, I guess you had to be there

A couple weeks later I joined another construction defense fleet – we were churning them outposts out now – which was also successful. Shortly afterwards the ISS agreed to take over and manage an outpost someone else had built in EC-P8R, pretty much on the other side of the universe. It’s one of the relatively rare cases where nullsec and highsec are directly adjacent, and such systems are anything but safe to travel through. So most Navy pilots packed their stuff (sigh) and moved to Pure Blind for a while, where we unsurpsisingly had quite a bit more action compared to Catch.

EVE_History11
My Megathron in a mixed battleship fleet of ours

Unfortunately some territorial alliances grew more and more wary of the ISS at that time, and before long reasons were looked for and found to attack us in force.

We had some allies and even hired the Mercenary Coalition to help us defend the outposts, but it ultimately was a fight we could not win, what with being attacked by numerous strong alliances both in the north and in the south at the same time.

All outposts were lost – they couldn’t be destroyed back then, but they were taken over and barred from public use like all the others – and while the ISS didn’t shut down immediately the dream of a public nullsec was effectively over.

It was then that I took my first break from EVE, but the story is far from over yet.

13 1/2 years of EVE Online – Part I

I didn’t play EVE much during the past six months or so. My relationship with the game has always been kinda on and off since I created my first character in December of 2005 – heck, is it really that long ago?

Anyway, after actively playing the game for a period of time my excitement always wanes and I start looking for greener pastures. But just as inevitably there’s always something that pulls me back in after a while. Sometimes it’s stories about galaxy-wide wars and huge battles, sometimes the announcement of an expansion or a much anticipated overhaul of existing features.

This time around it’s something else. Despite my inactivity I’m still a member of our long-time corp Holy Cookie, and last week our leadership informed us that sweeping changes are afoot. Unfortunately I can’t talk about those yet, but we’re very excited and I’ve been logged into the game every day since then.

As I can’t share that news today I’d like to look back upon my personal EVE history instead. The experiences I had, the people I’ve flown with, the changes the game went through. For EVE veterans there will undoubtedly be some ah, those were the times moments while newer players might find some insights as to what kinds of gameplay this vast sandbox has on offer. Since this will be a rather long tale I’ll split it into multiple parts.

Here goes.

EVE_History1
The second ever screenshot of my first ever frigate

Towards the end of 2005 a friend of mine had already played EVE for a while and tried to convince me and another pal to join him. He showed us a trailer – which looks terribly dated today, but amazed us back then – and some live gameplay. We were hooked.

Following his advice we both created Amarr characters. Lorewise I would have chosen Gallente or Minmatar for sure, but for some reason he believed that only Amarr characters would be able to join the corporation he was in. To my knowledge there never was such a restriction in the game, but by the time we realized that it was too late. Oh well, it’s not like I’ve ever roleplayed in EVE, nor have I ever been asked by anyone why I’ve chosen Amarr.

EVE_History2
Since 2011 I at least don’t have to look like a grumpy old man anymore

That little corp went by the name Tetragrammaton and already owned a little network of player owned stations (POSes) for moon mining, production and ratting. Their main system was N-8BZ6 in the Catch region. So I took what little stuff I had and moved out to nullsec, mere weeks after my first steps into the game.

EVE_History3
Two ships of mine, calmly floating in space with POS modules in the background

Once there I earned a ridiculously low amount of ISK by ratting in a Brutix class battlecruiser, the larger ship seen above. It’s not bad, but with Tech I fittings, Tech I ammo and skill levels at 2 or 3 I was in way over my head. Luckily my corpmates took me along when they manned their battleships and went to clear a nearby level 6/10 NPC complex, which were static at the time and respawned only after the daily server restart. Now that was much more lucrative.

Only a year or so later it would’ve been unthinkable for a meager six-man corp to ‘own’ such a complex. As the playerbase grew competition became increasingly fierce, and eventually the only thing CCP could do to prevent the large alliances from taking all good plexes for themselves was to remove the static ones and replace them with random spawns all over New Eden. In early 2006 though we had that one plex mostly for ourselves.

EVE_History4
At first I even ‘escorted’ their huge battleships in my tiny frigate

Much more interesting and even more lucrative were the industrial activities. The guys had decided to build and sell Hypersynaptic Fibers, an intermediate resource needed for all kinds of Tech II production. We had a couple moon mining POSes running, did some active mining – I just hauled the mined ore to the station in a Bestower because I hadn’t any mining skills – and had to keep the POSes fueled and the reactors running.

During that time I also learned the hard lessons that most EVE players have to learn sooner or later. Lessons like: you will lose a fully loaded hauler at the hands of pirates at some point, even if you’re cautious and warp core stabbed. While something like that isn’t fun for the player on the receiving end I managed to accept that it’s just part of the game, and from then on it felt all the more satisfying whenever I managed to slip through their grasp.

Unfortunately we couldn’t mine one of the required resources ourselves: Dysprosium. Those moons were among the rarest and most lucrative, and there was no way in hell for us to get our hands on one. So we had to buy the stuff on the market. It went pretty well for a while, but after a couple of months the ever rising Dysprosium price cut too deep into our margins, so we stopped production, sold the remaining ores as well as the towers and started to look for new enterprises. It was a great run though, and all told I earned somewhere between 600 and 800 million ISK, which was a fortune at the time, at least for me.

EVE_History5
My trusty Mammoth hauler safely docked up

It actually wasn’t a bad point in time for me to cease the industrial efforts, quite the contrary. I now had considerable seed capital at my disposal, and my character’s skills started to shape up as well. I felt ready and eager to finally engage in PvP!

Next time I’ll talk about how this led to me becoming a member of the Interstellar Starbase Syndicate and earning my first stripes as a space policeman.

EVE_History6
It even kinda looks like a police station, doesn’t it?

Case study: BDO’s business model

From my next post onward I’ll talk about playing games and having fun again instead of all this meta stuff, pinky promise. In fact I can hardly wait to talk about this:

MK11_Gang
It’s so good to see you again, old friends

First I’d like to get something out of the way though.

As you all know I’m a huge fan of Black Desert Online. If you’ve read my posts about it I assume you can understand why I enjoy it so much, even if the kinds of gameplay it offers might not be for you.

On the other hand, if your knowledge about the game mostly stems from what you’ve read somewhere else on the internet, for example in the comments over at Massively OP, you are probably under the impression that it’s a mismanaged, RNG-riddled, Pay to Win trainwreck, albeit a good looking one.

If that were true, and I were still supporting it financially despite of what I talked about in my last two posts, that’d make me quite the hypocrite, wouldn’t it? Maybe I am. I guess that’s in the eye of the beholder, as everything.

Anyway, today I’ll talk a bit about the game’s business model, and why I’m ok with it.

BDO_Shop
The shop front sure ain’t subtle

First of all, its monetization isn’t perfect. Far from it, actually. The game definitely encourages you to open your wallet, and I’d say you need to spend about 70-100 bucks total to be able to really enjoy the experience. In my opinion it’s totally worth that though. More than that even. There’s so much content to enjoy here, so much variety in things to do and classes to play, so much to explore; there just aren’t enough hours in the day to indulge in everything. It’s also still expanded and iterated upon on a weekly basis, years after launch. Pretty much every week’s patch notes have stuff in them that I’m happy about. Proper expansions have been huge, and always free of charge. I guess what I’m saying is, regardless of how much you actually decide to spend, you’ll definitely get a lot of bang for your buck here.

But let’s get down to the nitty-gritty of this business model, shall we?

Technically the game is Buy to Play. I say technically because buying it sets you back just 10 bucks, only half that during its quite regular discount periods. I realize that even at that price point it isn’t the same as F2P. Still, when I look at a game’s cash shop and ponder if I’m ok with it it makes a huge difference to me whether buying the game itself already costs 60 Euros, or just 5 or 10.

There’s an optional subscription called Value Pack. Many players say that you definitely need it, thus making it anything but optional. I do agree that it’s a big advantage to have every now and then, but I certainly don’t need it all the time. It gives a bunch of bonuses, the only really important of which is a reduction in marketplace sales tax. The math is a bit complicated, but the bottom line is that you get 85% of your item’s selling price with an active Value Pack, only 65% without. That is a pretty huge difference. The thing is, since I started playing the game I was gifted a total of twelve 7-day Value Packs just for logging in regularly, doing events and stuff. To this day I’ve only used up three of those to sell expensive goods I had stockpiled beforehand, so I don’t see me ever feel the need to actually buy a Value Pack for real money.

Of course the cash shop also sells all kinds of items we’ve already seen in most other such shops, if applicable. Costumes, weapon skins, pets, horse-, wagon- and ship-armor, furniture, consumable XP boosts, the works.

A big difference to most games I’ve played is that pretty much all those items do grant actual gameplay benefits here, which of course strongly reeks of P2W. And I guess it technically is. It doesn’t bother me though because once you understand how the game actually works you realize that most of these bonuses are negligible. Example: among other things costumes give a 10% bonus to combat XP. Not bad, but given the fact that you generally have bonuses amounting to at least 250% running whenever you actively grind for XP those additional 10% are but a drop in the bucket.

The item category that stands out are pets. You need some pets. Well, you can play without, but it won’t be much fun. What they do is pick up loot for you. Since you kill mobs by the thousands in this game, you really don’t want to pick up all that stuff by hand. New players get one pet as a login-reward pretty early on, but you’ll probably want to have more than one sooner rather than later.

BDO_Cat
Always by my side, wherever I go

I won’t go into detail about the game’s gear upgrading system again, I’ve already done that here and here. Suffice to say, there’s indeed a lot of RNG to it, and there are pretty severe consequences to failure on higher levels. Now, there are no items in the cash shop that actually increase your chances at a successful upgrade, but you can buy costumes and melt them down to Cron Stones. Those can be used while enhancing high grade gear to protect it from falling back one grade on failure. This is obviously pretty huge, and definitely P2W if you’re dead set on getting your gear to the highest tier of PvP-competitiveness. You’d have to pay a lot of money in order to do it this way though. I mean, a lot of money. Not dozens or hundreds, I’m talking thousands of Euros here.

And that doesn’t bother you? I hear you ask. Well, yes and no. Yes, I’d rather not have stuff like that in the game. Goes without saying, really. But also no, because if you’re willing and able to spend that much money just so the little numbers on your imaginary items are a bit higher than mine, more power to you. I’m serious. You and your peers basically keep the game afloat and development rolling single-handedly, which means that Lakisa and I don’t have to feel bad for playing countless hours without paying much for it. Also, we’ll never participate in Tier 3 node wars and stuff like that, so chances are you’ll never wield your shiny weapons against us anyway.

BDO_Lakisa&me
Besides, we’re far too good-looking for that kind of stuff

You see, the non-consensual part of the game’s PvP, despite of what you may have heard, is pretty much non-existent. I talked about how I had been ganked for the first time over a year ago. Since then it has happened to me just once more. Structured PvP, like the aforementioned node wars, is separated into tiers, with hard caps to attack power per tier. Bottom line is, you can engage in PvP and will still hardly ever be fighting significantly better geared players, unless you deliberately choose to. In consequence I really don’t care how those top geared players got their stuff. Yes, P2W still stinks, but it doesn’t ruin the game as a whole here like it would have done in, say, Battlefront II, hadn’t they reversed their course.

I obviously can’t go over each and every item on offer in the game’ shop, but this should suffice for a broad overview.

To summarize, I’m ok with BDO’s business model because it lets me play and enjoy an outstanding, content- and feature-rich virtual world for about the cost of a normal full-price game plus one paid expansion, and to me it’s worth much more than that. It has P2W aspects to it, but the way I see it those are pretty much irrelevant to all but the top 2% or less of players, and hence don’t affect me personally at all.

It sure isn’t perfect, but I actually enjoy spending money on the game every now and then. I don’t need to, I just want to. That’s saying something, isn’t it?